The 2009 budget was particularly severe for state dental care schemes. The PRSI scheme for dental benefits was drastically curtailed, limiting benefits to just one examination a year (even though workers were contributing to the scheme in expectation of dental and optical benefits). Dental Surgeons, including myself, were forced to think of introducing measures into their practices to help patients avail of affordable dental care. My article in Irish Dentist magazine shows the steps we took to help our patients. The budget also stated that the DTSS scheme (Medical Card scheme for dental treatment) would be examined.
On the 26th April 2010 a circular was sent to all dental surgeons participating in the medical card scheme by Patrick Burke of the HSE that effectively took a hatchet to the medical card scheme. It was to take place immediately and no dental surgeon had any prior warning that this would occur at this time. Mr Burke has since stated that all the concerns of Principal Dental Surgeons had been addressed by 2nd April 2010. It is quite clear from the letter sent to the HSE from the Pricipal Dental Surgeons on 30th April that this is not quite the case. The circular sent out to dental surgeons participating in the scheme stated that patients with Medical Cards could only avail of one examination a year and EMERGENCY TREATMENT ONLY. No more fillings (unless part of emergency care – an then only two are permitted at the most), no more cleanings , no more dentures unless part of emergency care and no more ectensive gum treatments (unless aproved due to ‘exceptional or high risk cases’). The HSE have not defined the term ‘emergency’ so there is little clarity as to what the term constitutes. The move by the HSE was immediately condemned by the media incuding most broadsheets, such as The Times and The Examiner and local papers also (See here and here). Television coverge also reported on the severity of the cutbacks.More recently, The Mail made more stark reading:
Mary Harney has said that the budget for dental care by the HSE is going to be set at the level it was back in 2008 of 63million euro. According to Minister Harney, the HSE funding cannot be increased. This is despite the number of medical cards in circulation rising by 270,000 in the last year due to the recession. There will almost certainly be an over run of this budget. The president of the Irish Dental Association’s Public Dental Surgeons Group, Dr Jane Renehan, estimates that 59.3 million of the 63 million euro budget has already been spent and we are only half way through the year! If Dr Renehan’s assessment is accurate, then the system is close to collapse.
Dental Surgeons who feel that their patients deserve treatment under the medical card scheme due to their patients medical situations must gain approval by the Principal Dental Surgeons. However, there are plenty of examples of worthy patients who have been denied care. The IDA documented these and presented them in a submission to the Joint Committee on Health and Children.
Two dental surgeons, Dr James Turner and Dr Martin Reid took the HSE to court to place an injunction over the HSE’s proposals and won. Both dentists claimed that the HSE has unilaterally varied the terms of their contracts and that this was done with no bi party discussions. A full court hearing is due as soon as possible. Both dentists have a significant proportion of their practices dedicated to treating patients with medical card patients. Many similar practices that used to see 20-30 medical card patients a day are now only seeing 2-3. Consequently practice turnover is down significantly by as much as 80%. Several practices will face hardship this year if the HSE implements come into force and already the amount of dentists being laid off is well into double figures.
It seems inevitable that dental costs for medical card holders will increase unless the court hearing in the autumn allows the scheme to continue in some form at least.
Despite dental practices reducing their fees significantly in the last year or so, Minister Harney continues to say that dentistry in the South is ‘too expensive’ compared to the north. The differences are not as large as they used to be and also in the north several practices are receiving grants for their practices which allows them to offer lower fees.
At Absolute Dental Care we are having to adhere to the circular strictly. Should the conditions of our contract change with the HSE we will keep everyone informed.


